An arbitrator will hear the case, consider evidence, and decide the outcome. Typically, arbitration ends with an award to one party or a dismissal of the case.Arbitration, 732-645-4300 ext. 88170. Find the best insurance claims attorney serving Middlesex. PIP Arbitration is a process that allows medical providers and insurance companies to resolve disputes and collect owed compensation. Fill out the contact form or call us at 609-799-6066 or 732-218-4110 to schedule your free consultation.