File online using the New York Insurance ADR Center online version of the Arbitration Request form (AAA Form AR1). Upload documents stored on your desktop.Org to register for an account. What Is a No-Fault Arbitration Process? Attorneys at The Sigalov Firm PLLC can help you navigate the complicated arbitration process and fight for the compensation you deserve. Providers must fill out and submit specific forms in order to proceed with the arbitration process, and specific timelines must be met. Process for Filing a No-Fault Arbitration Case. Before you can file a claim, the insurance company must have denied or failed to respond to your claim. Within three years of the date each claim payment was made.