Under New York Law, replevin is the correct cause of action to bring against a person who refuses to give you your comfort animal back. Basically, replevin is a term used to describe suing for the return of property, which is known as "chattel." Pets generally fall into the "chattel" category. Consider first a lawyer letter seeking return of the dog to avoid litigation. Rincker Law can help parties negotiate, litigate or mediate dog possession cases after a breakup. Get in touch at 785-727-9789. How Do I File My Replevin Action In Small Claims Court, And What Should I Expect? If you are seeking immediate return of your dog, a bond is required at double the value, to protect the defending party against wrongful action. Summary: This case is an appeal concerning an agreement to share possession of a dog between a couple that had ended their relationship. 14 fine could be covered in a civil action. The.