Under New York Law, replevin is the correct cause of action to bring against a person who refuses to give you your comfort animal back. Basically, replevin is a term used to describe suing for the return of property, which is known as "chattel." Pets generally fall into the "chattel" category. A writ of replevin is a prejudgment process ordering the seizure or attachment of alleged illegally taken or wrongfully withheld property. Replevin is an effective civil remedy to get your dog back. Small Claims Filing. An action in the Small Claims Division shall commence upon the filing of a complaint which shall state the amount and nature of the claim. Here are some examples of evidence that a plaintiff could present to prove their case in a replevin action. And West Chester, Ohio. Contact us at 877.644.