MORSE, J. Replevin for a cow. Sherwood, having already paid for the cow, sued for its possession under the writ of replevin.When defendant refused to deliver the cow, plaintiff brought a replevin action, arguing that title had passed. The case of Sherwood v. Walker was an argument over a cow and set a precedent that has been cited in over fifty cases across the United States. He found that the circuit court erred in ruling that it was immaterial whether the cow was pregnant. Replevin for a cow, Suit commenced in justice? Chicago (Iowa 1882): Defendant's train ran over plaintiff's cow. Wayne B. Wheeler controlled six Congresses, dictated to two. To be the res in a writ of replevin;.