Report a Claim Online. To assist us in determining benefits that may be due the applicant, please provide us with the answer to the following questions.A Subrogation Letter should clearly state the facts of the case, including details of the incident (e.g. This form is designed as a general form for use with respect to all claims. Some of the questions may not be applicable to your particular claim. The "filing a claim" process with the above linked form is the correct method for filing claims for damages to person or property. Locate an Agent 5 Broad Street PO Box 400 Branchville, NJ 07826 Phone (800) 336-3642 Fax (973) 948-7190 Be sure to properly complete your claim form. There are two ways for policyholders to start a claim online: Sign in to our online Customer Care Center and navigate to the Claims section. The employer may have separate insurance coverage covering the co-worker.