Our experienced New York criminal defense attorneys can challenge your confession under the Fifth Amendment and the Miranda rule. And yet, Miranda warnings do not need to be given upon arrest, unless you're on a TV show.If you are arrested, you should remain silent. Do not make any statements to police, except to say that you want to speak to your attorney. However, the police can still talk to you without needing to read you your Miranda rights, so long as you are not placed under arrest. Miranda rights are only applicable for questioning. If they found he had an outstanding warrant they need not give him any Miranda rights. The Supreme Court ruled in Payton v. New York, 445 US 573 (1980) that the Fourth Amendment prohibits police from entering a suspect's home without a warrant. If you voluntarily go to a police station to clear up a misunderstanding, the police aren't required to give you your Miranda warnings.