If the plaintiff or defendant has properly filed a jury demand and paid the jury demand fee, the case will be tried before a jury. Most civil trials in New York use only six jurors instead of the typical 12 in a criminal case.To reach the jury office in Buffalo, dial 716-551-1520. If your call is not answered, please leave a voice mail message. As opposed to criminal trials where unanimous jury decisions are required, civil cases in New York require that five out of six jurors agree to reach a verdict. You can complete the Juror Qualification Questionnaire on-line or you can complete the form, sign it, and return it in the business reply envelope. However, jury trials are also permitted in many civil cases in New York. New York Civil Practice Law and Rules CVP NY CPLR Section 4102. Two things about Trumsp civil fraud trial. Pursuant to CPLR §4109, in civil trials in New York each side has.