Both sides agree to arbitration. You choose between and arbitrator and a judge.In these situations, the ICDR can proceed if the other side agrees. 4 Under both federal and New York arbitration law, courts will uphold contractual agreements regarding the manner in which notice of arbitration is to be made. With the consent of the parties, volunteer arbitrators hear and decide smallclaims disputes. Arbitration is compulsory for civil cases where money damages being sought do not exceed. On this page you will learn how to file an arbitration claim, how to request mediation, and what documents are required for each process. This guide encompasses eight relevant arbitration topics with the aim of offering a comprehensive overview of arbitration in New York. This chapter primarily addresses the reach and import of the FAA on international arbitration agreements and arbitral proceedings seated in New York. ARTICLE 75. Arbitration. next.