The ability to appeal an order that compels arbitration depends on whether the district court dismisses the civil action. New York Rules of Civil Procedure - Motion to Compel Arbitration Kings - Supreme Court of the State of New York - Local and Federal Court Rules Made Easy.As such, the Federal Arbitration Act, 9. Section 4 of the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) allows you to file a Motion to Compel Arbitration even if the plaintiff hasn't filed a lawsuit against you. To file a suit to compel arbitration in federal court, the court must have subject matter jurisdiction and personal jurisdiction, venue must be proper. A Toolkit of resources to help counsel submit an application to a US federal or state court requesting an order to compel or stay arbitration. Even if you are unable to file in federal court, you can still file in state court because the FAA applies at the state level. A Motion to Compel can be filed only after you have made a formal discovery request under. Application of U.S. law to Plaintiff's statutory claims in the Bermuda arbitration.