A debt settlement letter is all you need to negotiate debts with your creditors. It asks you to pay a certain settlement amount to the collection agency.Crafting a debt settlement letter properly can help you get your creditors to accept your proposal. Learn how to write correctly one now. A good debt settlement letter should be concise, thorough, and convincing enough to get a creditor to agree to your terms. If you reject a settlement offer, or fail to keep up with a payment arrangement, your creditor might take you to court. Not sure about how to counter your creditor's debt settlement offer? Download this free Debt Settlement Offer Letter sample. Is settling with a credit card company a long term benefit? 2. What happens if I decide to not take the offer from the settlement company?