Mr. Orndorff argued that Erie's failure to accept his November 2016 demand constituted an improper rejection of "an opportunity to settle. I looked back at some rejection letters I sent and realized that I usually follow a pretty simple format: Say thanks.What Happens After Rejecting an Insurance Settlement Offer in Maryland. You might have several legal options to choose from after you reject a settlement offer. Most jurisdictions require a meet-and-confer letter for deficient discovery request responses before you can file a motion to compel. What happens if you reject a settlement letter depends on why you have rejected it and where you are in the negotiating process. Typically, once an insurance company has made a settlement offer, they will not retract it. View on Westlaw or start a FREE TRIAL today, § . Letter to Client Recommending Rejection of Settlement Offer, Legal Forms. Accept No Settlement Offers Without Serious Consideration.