Complete the Creditor's Claim that you received from the claimant. We have thoroughly evaluated our financial situation and, unfortunately, we are unable to meet the revised terms outlined in the counter offer.If you decide to reject the settlement offer, you'll need to do so in writing. Always reject a settlement offer in writing. Type a letter to your contact at the insurance company listing the reasons you think that their offer is too low. Learn "do's and don'ts" of returning rejected offers, and some options for dealing with rejecting multiple offers on a property. So we put in offer for a property yesterday and the RE agent came back with a counter offer that is higher than we would like to pay. If you're buried in offers (usually a good problem to have), this webinar covers some key points to know to stay out of trouble. How do you counter offer a settlement letter? Your Court may have additional forms you must file in a case.