Learn how to rent a car with just your debit card, even with age restrictions, paperwork and extra deposits. 1. How does the Car Rental Program work?Renting a car and wanting to know the valid payment methods? Alamo offers flexible payment options including credit, debit cards, cash and pre-paid payments. What do you need to rent a car? You need a valid driver's license or ID and a valid credit or debit card for paying a deposit to pick up a rental car. Wide selection of debit card car hire through New York JFK International Airport. Discounted prices for premium car rental packages. The same credit or debit card used to complete an online Pay Now reservation must be presented at the rental pick-up counter as a form of identification. Debit cards are accepted for payment at the end of your rental regardless of vehicle type rented.