The arbitration of claims can take several different forms in Pennsylvania, but can be generally categorized as either compulsory judicial arbitration. 1. Complete the attached Arbitrator Application form. 2.Complete a W-9 form found in the Arbitration forms section on the Civil. Typically an arbitration award is in the form of paying damages. As experienced insurance claim attorneys, we are here to guide you through every step of the arbitration process and ensure you receive the outcome you deserve. Instead of filing a lawsuit, the insurer and the policyholder present their case to the arbitrator.