Most likely phishy, however each state does have an unclaimed property program that does exist. Hiring an attorney for unemployment benefits is pretty much never necessary as the system is set up so that you don't need a lawyer.If you were overpaid, you will receive a written notice in the mail. To be considered for a waiver, you must complete and return the Personal Financial Statement (DE 1446). A guide and tips for Ohio Unemployment Appeal Letters, including a sample template, from experienced unemployment attorneys. Many insurers will offer to deduct the overpaid amount from your future monthly benefits.