Puerto Rico Jury Instruction — 7.2 Duty To Deliberate When Both Plaintiff and Defendant Claim Damages or When Damages Are Not an Issue constitutes a significant aspect of the legal process in Puerto Rico. This jury instruction addresses the responsibility of the jury members to carefully consider and discuss the evidence presented when both the plaintiff and the defendant claim damages, or when damages are not a disputed matter. In cases where both the plaintiff and the defendant assert damages, the jury must fulfill their duty to deliberate by thoroughly examining the evidence, testimony, and any relevant documentation. They must assess the extent of the harm or losses suffered by both parties and determine whether the claimed damages are justified. This requires the jury to closely analyze the facts and arguments put forth by both sides before reaching a fair and reasonable decision regarding the award of damages. Additionally, this jury instruction is also applicable when damages are not an issue in the case. In such instances, the jury's responsibility to deliberate remains crucial, although the focus shifts to determining liability or other relevant issues without considering damages. By evaluating the evidence presented, weighing witness credibility, and thoroughly discussing their findings, the jury must arrive at a well-reasoned verdict based on the applicable laws and legal principles. It is important to note that specific types or variations of Puerto Rico Jury Instruction — 7.2 Duty To Deliberate When Both Plaintiff and Defendant Claim Damages or When Damages Are Not an Issue may exist, depending on the circumstances of the case, the nature of the claims made, and the instructions provided by the presiding judge. However, the fundamental principle underlying this instruction remains consistent — the duty of the jury to engage in a thoughtful and comprehensive deliberation process to ensure a just outcome that considers the factual and legal aspects of the case. In summary, Puerto Rico Jury Instruction — 7.2 emphasizes the obligation of the jury to deliberate when both the plaintiff and defendant claim damages or when damages are not an issue. By carefully examining the evidence, assessing the credibility of witnesses, and applying the relevant laws, the jury's discussion and analysis play a critical role in facilitating a fair and impartial resolution to the case.