Utah Jury Instruction — 5.1 Expert Witnesses General Instruction provides guidance to jurors regarding the evaluation and consideration of expert witnesses' testimony during a trial. Expert witnesses play a crucial role in providing specialized knowledge and opinion in areas beyond the knowledge of an average juror. This instruction assists jurors in understanding the nature of expert testimony, how to assess its credibility, and the weight it should carry in reaching a verdict. In Utah, there are different types of 5.1 Expert Witnesses General Instructions that are tailored to specific circumstances. Variations may include: 1. Utah Jury Instruction — 5.1.1 Defendant's Expert Witnesses: This instruction focuses explicitly on expert witnesses called by the defense. It highlights the importance of considering the qualifications, opinions, and the grounds for those opinions provided by the defense's expert witnesses. Jurors are urged to evaluate the credibility and relevance of the expert's testimony within the context of the entire case. 2. Utah Jury Instruction — 5.1.2 Plaintiff's Expert Witnesses: This instruction is aimed at explaining the significance of expert witnesses called by the plaintiff. It directs jurors to assess the qualifications, opinions, and the basis for those opinions put forth by the plaintiff's expert witnesses. Jurors are reminded to consider the credibility and applicability of the expert's testimony against the backdrop of the entire case. 3. Utah Jury Instruction — 5.1.3 Mutual Expert Witnesses: This instruction caters to situations where both the plaintiff and the defense present expert witnesses. It advises jurors to scrutinize the qualifications, opinions, and the foundation for those opinions given by expert witnesses from both parties. Jurors are encouraged to compare the credibility and relevance of these expert testimonies before reaching any conclusions. The purpose of these instructions is to equip jurors with the necessary knowledge and tools to evaluate the evidence presented by expert witnesses in an informed and unbiased manner. They help ensure that jurors understand the weight that should be given to such expert testimony and prevent them from relying solely on subjective opinions or personal biases. By following the guidelines provided in Utah Jury Instruction — 5.1 Expert Witnesses General Instruction, jurors are encouraged to approach expert testimony with a critical eye, considering the qualifications, opinions, and factual basis presented by each expert witness. Ultimately, these instructions assist jurors in making well-informed and fair decisions based on the evidence presented during a trial.