Utah Jury Instruction — 7.2 Duty To Deliberate When Both Plaintiff and Defendant Claim Damages or When Damages Are Not an Issue is an important guideline that provides instructions to jurors on their responsibilities during deliberations in cases where both the plaintiff and the defendant claim damages or when damages are not an issue. This instruction aims to ensure a fair and thorough consideration of the evidence and arguments presented by both parties. When both the plaintiff and the defendant claim damages, jurors must carefully evaluate and weigh the evidence to determine the extent of each party's injuries and the appropriate amount of compensation. They are required to analyze the credibility and reliability of witness testimonies, expert opinions, and any other relevant evidence presented during the trial. Jurors should also consider the severity of any harm suffered, the potential long-term impact, and any financial losses incurred by the parties. In cases when damages are not an issue, jurors must still engage in the deliberation process to assess liability and allocate fault. They need to evaluate the evidence presented to determine whether the defendant's actions were negligent or caused harm to the plaintiff. This includes considering negligence laws, liability standards, and any applicable legal doctrines or principles discussed during the trial. Jurors should keep in mind that their duty is to arrive at a fair and just decision based on the facts presented and the instructions provided by the court. They should disregard any personal biases, prejudices, or sympathy towards either party when formulating their verdict. Different types of Utah Jury Instruction — 7.2 Duty To Deliberate When Both Plaintiff and Defendant Claim Damages or When Damages Are Not an Issue may include variations or modifications specific to different types of civil cases, such as personal injury, medical malpractice, contract disputes, or product liability cases. Each variation may provide context and guidance that is particular to the legal elements involved in those specific types of cases. It is important for jurors to pay close attention to the specific instructions provided by the court regarding their duty to deliberate in cases where damages are claimed by both parties or are not at issue. Following these instructions diligently ensures a fair and just resolution of the case and upholds the principles of justice and the rule of law.