Label Comment Paper For Free

Confidential comments to the editor may be the appropriate place to discuss sensitive information or opinions, including any potential ethical issues with the work, or information that cannot be shared with other reviewers, such as any previous interaction with the manuscript at another journal, but should in no way ...

Use a short title that emphasizes your key message. (It should be clear in context that all commentaries are a reaction to a particular paper). Do not include an abstract. Make clear your take-home message.

Try to be specific in your comments For example, instead of saying, ?I really loved your blog post, it was so informative and I learned so much from you,? say instead, ?I hadn't thought about this particular thing you pointed out, and it'd help me in doing so and so.? You could also add to the conversation too.

In a comment, present your opinion, but give reasons (with reference to the text) ? if possible, refute counter arguments; start with your weakest argument and move on to the strongest argument. Paragraphs should end with a valid conclusion; in a comment, make a personal conclusion and restate your opinion.

Aim at adding feedback that is detailed, focused, relevant to the research item, and useful to the people reading it. A useful comment is one that either asks a specific question or provides feedback on the content, method, results, or anything else specific to someone's research.

The following simple structure will help you present your comments in an organized way: Reflect back the paper's main point. ... Discuss the essay's strengths. ... Discuss the paper's weaknesses, focusing on large problems first. ... Type your final comments if possible.

Adding a good comment Aim at adding feedback that is detailed, focused, relevant to the research item, and useful to the people reading it. A useful comment is one that either asks a specific question or provides feedback on the content, method, results, or anything else specific to someone's research.