Model Comment Paper For Free

Make sure to include feedback on the strengths, as well as the weaknesses, of the manuscript. Examples and explanations of those should consume most of the review. Provide details of what the authors need to do to improve the paper. Point out both minor and major flaws and offer solutions.

When preparing a comment about a published manuscript, simply reference the paper in question and clearly state the reasons you are critiquing it one by one. The authors are then asked to respond to the critique in the same manner.

The following simple structure will help you present your comments in an organized way: Reflect back the paper's main point. ... Discuss the essay's strengths. ... Discuss the paper's weaknesses, focusing on large problems first. ... Type your final comments if possible.

Be polite. ... Never assume a reviewer is ?stupid? or a nonexpert. ... Respond to ALL queries and ALL author instructions. ... Provide thorough responses. ... Make it EASY for the reviewer and editor to understand your response. ... If you do not understand a review comment, it is okay to admit it. ... Conclusion.

Adding a good comment Aim at adding feedback that is detailed, focused, relevant to the research item, and useful to the people reading it. A useful comment is one that either asks a specific question or provides feedback on the content, method, results, or anything else specific to someone's research.

Aim at adding feedback that is detailed, focused, relevant to the research item, and useful to the people reading it. A useful comment is one that either asks a specific question or provides feedback on the content, method, results, or anything else specific to someone's research.

Summary Give positive feedback first. ... Briefly summarize what the paper is about and what the findings are. Try to put the findings of the paper into the context of the existing literature and current knowledge. Indicate the significance of the work and if it is novel or mainly confirmatory.