San Diego California Jury Instruction — 1.2 With Counterclaim By Defendant is a legal instruction given to the jury in a civil trial in San Diego, California. This particular instruction pertains to cases where the defendant in the lawsuit not only denies the allegations made by the plaintiff but also files a counterclaim against the plaintiff. In such cases, the jury is instructed to consider both the plaintiff's claims and the defendant's counterclaim separately. They are responsible for evaluating the evidence presented by both parties and determining the merits of each claim. The San Diego California Jury Instruction — 1.2 With Counterclaim By Defendant is designed to guide the jury in properly understanding their role and responsibilities in the context of a counterclaim. It emphasizes the need for the jury to assess the evidence independently and make separate findings for both the plaintiff's claim and the defendant's counterclaim. The purpose of this instruction is to ensure that the jury comprehends the complexities of the case and makes an informed decision based on the evidence presented. It helps prevent any confusion or bias that may arise from combining the plaintiff's claims and the defendant's counterclaim. Different types of San Diego California Jury Instruction — 1.2 With Counterclaim By Defendant may include variations based on the specific nature of the counterclaim. For example, there could be instructions specific to counterclaims involving property disputes, contractual breaches, personal injuries, or professional negligence. These variations tailor the instruction to the specific legal issues involved in the given case, providing detailed guidance to the jury regarding relevant laws, burdens of proof, and legal standards. In summary, San Diego California Jury Instruction — 1.2 With Counterclaim By Defendant is an important legal instruction that helps the jury understand their role when evaluating both the plaintiff's claim and the defendant's counterclaim in a civil trial.