Mecklenburg County, North Carolina, Jury Instruction — 7.2 Duty To Deliberate When Both Plaintiff and Defendant Claim Damages or When Damages Are Not an Issue is an important legal instruction given to juries during civil trials. This instruction guides jurors on their responsibility to carefully deliberate and reach a fair decision when both the plaintiff and defendant claim damages, or when damages are not a central issue in the case. These instructions help ensure that the jury understands their duty to consider the evidence presented and make a just and informed verdict. In cases where both the plaintiff and defendant claim damages, it is crucial for jurors to carefully analyze the evidence, witness testimonies, and any other relevant factors that may affect the claims. They must assess the credibility of each party's claims and weigh the evidence presented to determine the extent of damages, if any, suffered by each party. The jury should consider factors such as medical reports, financial records, expert opinions, and any other evidence that helps ascertain the extent of damages. When damages are not a central focus of the case, this jury instruction emphasizes that jurors should not dismiss or downplay the importance of damages altogether. Even if damages are not a primary concern, the jury must still consider the evidence related to damages and make an appropriate determination. This instruction ensures that the jury understands the importance of giving equal consideration to all aspects of the case, including damages, regardless of their relevance to the core issues being litigated. Different types of Mecklenburg North Carolina Jury Instruction — 7.2 Duty To Deliberate When Both Plaintiff and Defendant Claim Damages or When Damages Are Not an Issue may be specific to the nature of the case being tried. For instance, cases involving personal injury claims, contract disputes, property damage disputes, or defamation claims would each have unique considerations and instructions based on applicable legal principles. The jury instructions provided by the court would be tailored to address the circumstances and legal elements involved in each specific case.